Log in Sign up

Overview

In July 1897 the English composer Edward Elgar (later famous for the Enigma Variations) slipped a short coded note into a letter his wife sent to the family of Dora Penny, a 23-year-old friend he nicknamed "Dorabella". Dora could never read it. She published it in 1937, three years after Elgar's death, in her memoir Edward Elgar: Memories of a Variation.

Date14 July 1897 (date of the covering letter)
AuthorSir Edward Elgar
Length87 characters in three lines
Alphabet24 different symbols: groups of one, two or three small arcs in eight orientations
Plaintext languageEnglish (almost certain)
StatusUnsolved

Why the plaintext is English

Elgar and Dora Penny were both English, and the note was a personal message between friends. Elgar loved word games, puns and phonetic spelling, so the plaintext may be playful, misspelled or full of in-jokes. That is a big part of why it is hard.

What is known

  • Elgar used the same arc-symbols elsewhere, and in an 1896 notebook he solved a substitution cipher from a magazine. So he knew simple ciphers well.
  • 24 symbols in 8 orientations × 3 arc counts look made for a simple substitution (one symbol per letter, with I/J and U/V merged).
  • The letter frequencies fit English roughly, but no clean substitution solution has been found.
  • A 2023 computer study by Viktor Wase found that algorithms which reliably solve English substitution ciphers this short fail on Dorabella. That suggests it is not a plain monoalphabetic substitution of normal English. It may be phonetic, abbreviated, have extra steps, or contain mistakes.

Proposed solutions

Many have been put forward (Eric Sams in 1970, Tim S. Roberts, Tony Gaffney and others), and the Elgar Society ran a competition in 2007. None is accepted, because each needs special rules that could produce almost any text.

Tips for solvers

  • Try phonetic English, Elgar's private jokes and nicknames, and words related to music or to the Penny family.
  • Read the symbols in all orientations. The direction the arcs face is part of the key.
  • Look at the other unsolved Elgar cryptograms (see Schmeh's link below). They use the same style.

See also Unsolved Ciphers: Overview.

Put together with AI as a quick reference I keep for my own work. Entries like this are usually not reviewed in detail by a person.