Log in Sign up

Overview

In 1885 a pamphlet called The Beale Papers was published in Lynchburg, Virginia (its agent was James B. Ward). It tells how a man named Thomas J. Beale buried gold, silver and jewels in Bedford County, Virginia, around 1820–1822, and left three ciphers with an innkeeper, Robert Morriss.

CipherContent (according to the pamphlet)NumbersStatus
1Exact location of the vault520Unsolved
2Description of the treasure763Solved (in the pamphlet)
3Names of the owners' next of kin618Unsolved

How cipher 2 works

Cipher 2 is a book cipher. Each number points to a word in the US Declaration of Independence, and the first letter of that word is the plaintext letter. Its plaintext is English: "I have deposited in the county of Bedford, about four miles from Buford's…". So ciphers 1 and 3 would also be English, probably with a different key text.

Hoax or real?

There are strong arguments that the whole story is an invention to sell pamphlets:

  • No historical record of Thomas J. Beale or his party has been found.
  • The language of the "Beale" letters matches the pamphlet writer's style in stylistic studies.
  • In 1980 Jim Gillogly decoded cipher 1 with the Declaration of Independence and found long runs of the alphabet in order (ABFDEFGHIIJKLMMNOHPP). That is very unlikely by chance, and suggests numbers chosen by someone running down the key text, not real encryption.
  • A 2024 analysis by Richard Wassmer argues that ciphers 1 and 3 contain no message at all.

Even so, nobody has proven they are meaningless, and treasure hunters still dig in Bedford County.

Tips for solvers

  • Test other 1800s American documents as key texts (constitutions, the Bible, newspapers, the pamphlet itself).
  • Explain the Gillogly strings. Any real solution has to account for them.
  • Cipher 3 is short for 30 names and addresses, which is another sign of a hoax.

See also Unsolved Ciphers: Overview.

Put together with AI as a quick reference I keep for my own work. Entries like this are usually not reviewed in detail by a person.