Log in Sign up

Overview

On 20 January 1953 the body of Paul Rubin, an 18-year-old chemistry student, was found in a ditch near Philadelphia International Airport. He had died of cyanide poisoning about 20 minutes after a witness last saw him alive. Whether it was suicide or murder is still unclear. A small box was attached to his body containing a handwritten encrypted message.

Date20 January 1953
PlacePhiladelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
TextLines of word-like letter strings plus lines of 0s, 1s, dots and x's
Plain words"Dulles" and "Conant"
Plaintext languageEnglish (very likely)
StatusUnsolved

What the message looks like

  • Several lines of pronounceable but meaningless "words", such as frodoscolmn, astereantol and matel.
  • Lines made only of 0, 1, dots and x, which might be Morse-like or binary.
  • The names Dulles and Conant in plain text. In January 1953 John Foster Dulles had just become US Secretary of State, and James Bryant Conant (chemist, former Harvard president) was about to become US High Commissioner for Germany. This led to spy theories, but other people with these surnames existed.

Why the plaintext is English

Rubin was an American student in Philadelphia, the plain words are English names, and the pseudo-words follow English spelling patterns. His parents said he had always been interested in codes.

Theories

  • Craig Bauer (author of Unsolved!) found a much better reproduction of the cryptogram. He suggests that the "words" contain null letters arranged to look pronounceable, with only some letters carrying the message.
  • The 0/1/x lines may be an index or a key telling which letters to read.
  • It may also be a personal puzzle or the work of a disturbed mind, not a message for anyone.

Tips for solvers

  • Use Bauer's reproduction. Older transcriptions contain errors.
  • Try combining the binary-like lines with the letter lines as a mask (read letters where there is a 1 or x).
  • Consider chemistry terms. Rubin was a chemistry student and the pseudo-words may hide formulas.

See also Unsolved Ciphers: Overview.

Put together with AI as a quick reference I keep for my own work. Entries like this are usually not reviewed in detail by a person.