What is in this category
These entries cover unsolved ciphers and coded messages whose plaintext is almost certainly English or German. We left out mysteries in unknown or invented languages (such as the Voynich Manuscript or the Rohonc Codex) and anything that has been solved.
| Entry | Year | Language | Length | Difficulty / notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kryptos K4 | 1990 | English | 97 letters | Official plaintext clues; method unknown |
| Zodiac Killer Ciphers Z13 and Z32 | 1970 | English | 13 + 32 symbols | Probably too short to prove any solution |
| The Dorabella Cipher | 1897 | English | 87 symbols | Likely substitution, but with a twist |
| The Beale Ciphers | 1885 | English | 520 + 618 numbers | Book cipher; possibly a hoax |
| Ricky McCormick's Encrypted Notes | 1999 | English | ~30 lines | Probably personal shorthand |
| The Somerton Man (Tamam Shud) Code | 1948 | English | ~50 letters | Probably initial letters of words |
| The D'Agapeyeff Cipher | 1939 | English | 196 digit pairs | Textbook challenge; maybe encryption errors |
| The WWII Carrier Pigeon Message (Bletchingley) | ~1944 | English | 27 × 5 letters | Codebook (+ one-time pad?); needs the book |
| Cicada 3301: The Liber Primus | 2014 | English | ~55 pages of runes | Modern stream cipher; large ciphertext |
| The Paul Rubin Cryptogram | 1953 | English | Several lines | Probably nulls / masking |
| The YOG'TZE Note (Günther Stoll, 1984) | 1984 | German | 6 letters | Not cryptanalysable; context puzzle |
A note on German ciphers
Many well-known German "unsolved" cryptograms have been solved or explained in recent years. That is largely thanks to the readers of Klaus Schmeh's blog Cipherbrain:
- The Rilke cryptogram (WWII) turned out to be typing practice, not a message.
- The SS radio message to Lippert (1944) is most likely a forgery.
- Most of the 1918 ADFGVX messages were broken by George Lasry and others.
Many small German items (encrypted postcards, diaries) are still open. Schmeh's blog is the best place to find them, and new ones appear there regularly.
General tips for would-be solvers
- Start from the best images. Retyped transcripts often contain errors that make a solution impossible.
- Know the context. Who wrote it, when, and for whom tells you which ciphers they could have used.
- Respect the unicity distance. Very short ciphertexts (Z13, Z32, YOG'TZE) have many "solutions". Without a key that explains how, a readable text proves nothing.
- Test against known facts. For Kryptos K4, any method must reproduce EAST, NORTHEAST, BERLIN and CLOCK. For Beale, it must explain the Gillogly strings.
- Use good tools. CrypTool 2, dCode and AZdecrypt handle substitution, transposition and homophonic ciphers.
- Publish your method, not just your plaintext, so others can check it.
Good background sources
- Klaus Schmeh, "The Top 50 unsolved encrypted messages": https://scienceblogs.de/klausis-krypto-kolumne/the-top-50-unsolved-encrypted-messages/
- Elonka Dunin's list of famous unsolved codes: http://elonka.com/UnsolvedCodes.html
- Nick Pelling's Cipher Mysteries blog: https://ciphermysteries.com/
- Wikipedia, list of ciphertexts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ciphertexts
- Craig Bauer, Unsolved! The History and Mystery of the World's Greatest Ciphers (Princeton University Press, 2017)
- CrypTool 2 (free cryptanalysis software): https://www.cryptool.org/
- dCode (online cipher tools): https://www.dcode.fr/
Put together with AI as a quick reference I keep for my own work. Entries like this are usually not reviewed in detail by a person.