Overview
In 1982 David Martin found the skeleton of a carrier pigeon in the chimney of his house in Bletchingley, Surrey, England. Attached to its leg was a small red canister with a handwritten message on a "Pigeon Service" form. When it became public in 2012, the message went to GCHQ, Britain's signals intelligence agency.
| Probable date | Second World War, possibly around D-Day (June 1944) |
| Found | Bletchingley, Surrey, UK |
| Text | 27 groups of five letters |
| Other details | Pigeon IDs NURP.40.TW.194 and NURP.37.OK.76; signed "Sjt W Stot"; codes "X02" and time "1625" |
| Plaintext language | English (British military message) |
| Status | Unsolved |
Why the plaintext is English
The form is a British Army/RAF pigeon service form, signed by a British sergeant, and probably addressed to a British unit ("X02" is thought to be the recipient, perhaps Bomber Command). Before encryption the plaintext would therefore be English, though first turned into codewords.
Why GCHQ says it is unbreakable
In November 2012 GCHQ concluded the message can't be decoded "without access to the original cryptographic material". Wartime messages like this were usually turned into codewords from a codebook, and often super-enciphered with a one-time pad. If the pad was used correctly, the message is mathematically unbreakable without it. The books and pads were normally destroyed after the war.
Claimed solutions
A Canadian researcher, Gord Young, claimed in 2012 to have decoded it with a WWI artillery codebook, as a report about German troop positions in Normandy. GCHQ and most experts did not accept it, because the method needs too many free choices.
Tips for solvers
- The best chance is not cryptanalysis but finding the codebook: archives, military museums, family papers of pigeon handlers.
- Research "Sjt W Stot", the two pigeon numbers and the code "X02" in war records.
- Treat any "solution" without a documented, period-correct codebook with caution.
Links
- GCHQ's official story: https://www.gchq.gov.uk/features/pigeon-takes-secret-message-grave
- Wikipedia, list of ciphertexts (Pigeon NURP 40 TW 194): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ciphertexts
- Klaus Schmeh, Top 50 #20 (the pigeon cryptogram): https://scienceblogs.de/klausis-krypto-kolumne/the-top-50-unsolved-encrypted-messages/
- ABC News report with the message: https://abcnews.go.com/blogs/headlines/2012/11/can-you-help-spies-crack-impossible-wwii-pigeon-code
See also Unsolved Ciphers: Overview.
Put together with AI as a quick reference I keep for my own work. Entries like this are usually not reviewed in detail by a person.